This
post was originally published on
this sitehttp://www.thekitchn.com/feedburnermain
For many, a whole turkey is the largest, heftiest grocery item that most of us haul into our kitchens all year. We hope our Thanksgiving Day bird is bronzed and beautiful, with juicy white breast meat and tender dark meat. But let’s be honest — that’s not an easy feat.
To that good end, we seek guidance, tips, and hints — year after year. If we roast only one turkey each year, we tend to forget last year’s lessons and need to refresh our game plan and seek a little reassurance. If we’ve never cooked a turkey in our lives, we need detailed how-tos and hand-holding.
With that in mind, I set out to test some of the most popular turkey recipes out there — from Alton Brown, Ina Garten, Martha Stewart, and Ree Drummond — to determine which one might deserve a spot on your Thanksgiving table this year. For the sake of a true comparison, I prepared the recipes exactly as written, no matter what I might have learned from reader comments or my own personal knowledge and years of experience. And I learned something from each, because there are always new tips and hints out there to help us.
Ree’s offered a homey, old-fashioned approach that reminded me of the way my grandmother made turkey, but with the benefit of a brine. Martha suggested a fascinating way to shield and moisten the delicate breast meat. Alton’s high-temperature blast created perfect browned skin. Ina streamlined a smart, simple path to a wonderful turkey.
So which turned out tops on my list? Here’s how they ranked, from my least favorite to most.
READ MORE »